Wine Advocate #197- Oct 2011
Score : 89
Guigal’s roses are also very strong efforts, but they tend to disappear from retailers’ shelves as quickly as they are released. The 2010 Cotes du Rhone Rose exhibits copious aromas of strawberries and cherries, a medium pink color, crisp acids and an elegant, mineral-like character. Robert Parker.
Wine Advocate #191 - Oct 2010
Score : 88
It is hard to say anything produced by Marcel and Philippe Guigal is under the consumer radar, but I do believe their roses are exceptional and compete with the best estate-bottled roses in southern France. The 2009 Cotes du Rhone Rose exhibits loads of raspberry, strawberry, garrigue, and spice in a complex, perfumed style that is dry, elegant, yet very flavorful. Robert Parker.
Wine Spectator - Oct 31, 2011
Score: 87
Firm and focused, with pomegranate and cherry notes backed by a hint of tobacco on the juicy finish. Drink now. James Molesworth.
Guide Bettane & Desseauve des Vins de France
Score : 15/20
Robe foncée, arômes de fruits rouges frais (soupe de fraise), la bouche est très gourmande, toujours dans ce style pulpeux savoureux, il est très proche du 2009.