Wine Spectator - Issue: Top 100: 2003, Rank: 30 - Sep 30, 2003
Score : 97
Ultrarich and ultrathick. A full-bodied, stunningly sweet-tasting Northern Rhône, it delivers a ripe mouthfeel and plenty of fruit, mineral and toasty, smoky character. Long, balanced finish. Great Hermitage red from Guigal. Drink now through 2012. 4,580 cases made. Per-Henrik Mansson
Stephen Tanzer's International Wine Cellar - Jan/Feb 03
Score : 90(+?)
Bright medium ruby. Very ripe aromas of cassis, gunflint, roasted herbs and spices. Expressive and mouthfilling; a very rich wine that's amazingly supple for such a young Hermitage. But also broad-shouldered and solidly structured. Finishes very long and ripely tannic. Stephen Tanzer.